Supreme Court Declines to Hear Appeal of Tussey v. ABB

Yesterday, November 10, 2014, the Supreme Court published an order declining to hear the appeal of the 8th Circuit decision in Tussey v. ABB from earlier this year. (see Tussey v. ABB Affirmed, Reversed, and Vacated in Part by 8th Circuit).

The Supreme Court does not provide a reason why they decline to hear appeals. However in this instance, there are at least a few speculative guesses. First, they have already agreed to hear two ERISA cases this term, with one being Tibble v. Edison and the other a retiree health care vesting case that had oral arguments recently. Second, on the issue of deference which was the heart of plaintiffs’ appeal, the district court will get to decide that issue for the first time. How the district court will decide could make the Supreme Court hearing the case unnecessary. The Supreme Court generally dislikes hearing cases that have an opportunity to work themselves out in the lower courts.

So what’s next? The case will now go back to the district court for it to decide the outstanding issue of deference and any lingering issues regarding attorney’s fees. I can guarantee one thing…this is not the last time we will hear about Tussey v. ABB.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *